Sunday, December 10, 2006

Pitcher Projections

As a rule, they suck. Much, much harder than projecting hitters.

For pitchers with at least 100 innings last year, Chone came in at .424, way lower than the near .700 range for hitters. This represents the correlation coefficient between projected ERA and actual ERA. The other projection systems didn't do much better:

.459 ZIPs
.445 Baseball Info Solutions (Bill James has nothing to do with this although its in his Handbook, he claims it can't be done)
.442 Marcel
.423 Shandler

Still waiting on the return of my 2006 Prospectus, so I can check PECOTA.

How about souting info? I tried putting together some projections based solely on a regression formula from scouting reports, with things like average fastball velocity, types of other pitches, quality of pitches, etc. Didn't do so hot:

.265. Of course, I'm no great scout, and a real scout attempting this with better scouting data might be able to do better.

The projections are better than using prior year ERA (.29) or prior year Fielding Independent Pitching (.37), though not much better than the latter.

I've heard some people claim that you shouldn't test a pitcher projection by looking at ERA anyway, you should look at component ERA or something. I don't buy that. I need ERA (or at least run average). Whether for fantasy baseball, where you need ERA to get results, or real baseball, where you need to keep real runs off the scoreboard, I don't give a damn if you can accurately predict component ERA. If you can't predict the real thing, then your system is useless.

Pitcher projections are a very inexact science. The only thing good I can say is as bad as they are, its better to have some flawed, not especially accurate idea of how a pitcher will do that to have no idea at all.

12 Comments:

At 4:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Chone,

I posted your projections over at http://mb8.scout.com/foaklandathleticsfrm1 .

Hope that's not a problem...

Keep up the good work.

 
At 7:21 PM, Blogger Chone Smith said...

No problem. I'll check it out.

 
At 3:27 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Chone,

This is really impressive! Is Marcel calculated with prior ERAs or prior FIPs or component ERAs or something else?

 
At 7:26 PM, Blogger Chone Smith said...

I can't answer for Marcel.

I assume you mean my projection system, Chone.

Runs is based on a pitcher's components through a base runs formula. Earned runs is simply runs * 0.92.

 
At 2:20 PM, Blogger Tangotiger said...

Component ERA is analogous to OPS. ERA is R, RBI, or RP, etc.

I think it's totally fair to compare component ERAs, if you are going to compare OPS for hitters.

 
At 5:17 PM, Blogger Chone Smith said...

I just posted this on the BTF thread:

"Just created a stat, runs + rbi per plate appearance. For CHONE in this sample, the r = .642, just a little lower than the r=.677 for OPS, but still way ahead of the pitching projections."

 
At 10:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have to agree that component ERA is a better stat to compare. Actual ERA just isn't a very good stat, there is way too much noise involved and a lot of it is completely out of the pitchers control.

You could completely accurately predict how well a pitcher pitches and be off by a full run in ERA because of dumb luck or bad luck on his part.

 
At 9:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

 CLOTHES-WHOLESALE.US
straighthairgirl.blog126.fc2.com/
seriousblogging.com/crazygirlsshirts
free-blog-site.com/iammyself
d.hatena.ne.jp/hotfishing
www3.atword.jp/deepseaworld
kandypurity.blogspot.com
blog.oricon.co.jp/jacket-love-girl/
blog.goo.ne.jp/sweetyjackets
blog.360.yahoo.com/
azcentral.com/members/Blog/hotfish234
www2.atword.jp/chaussurespuma/
www2.atword.jp/edhardyshirts/
edhardywomens.blogspot.com/
weddingdressseason.com
seriousblogging.com/chaussurenike/
blog.goo.ne.jp/yutome
d.hatena.ne.jp/chaussuresport/
mensjacketscheap.blogspot.com/
pumashoes.cocolog-nifty.com/blog/
free-blog-site.com/mensjeans
d.hatena.ne.jp/womenjeanswholesale/
www2.atword.jp/wholesalejean/
blog.goo.ne.jp/cheapjeans
blog.360.yahoo.com/

 
At 3:38 AM, Anonymous London Escort Agency said...

Your Escort Agency offers exclusive and most beautiful London escort girls of various nationalities.

 
At 2:13 PM, Anonymous London escorts said...

Bestescort4U agency provids best London escorts companionship in the UK.

 
At 2:47 PM, Blogger Bayan Ankara Escort said...

Ankara Escort, Escort Ankara, Escort Ankara Bayan
Escort Ankara, Escort Ankara Bayan, Ankara Escort Bayan
Bayan Ankara Escort, Ankara Bayan Escort, Ankara Escort Kızlar
Escort Kızlar Ankara, Escort Bayan Ankara, Escort Bayanlar Ankara
Escort Bayanlar Ankara, Ankara Bayan Escortlar, Ankara Eskort Bayan
Escort Kızlar Ankara, Ankara Escort Kadınlar, Ankara Eskort Bayanlar
Ankarada Tele Kızlar, Ankara Escort Kızlar, Ankara Eskort Bayan
Bursa Escort, Bayan Escort Bursa, Bursa Eskort Bayan
Kayseri Escort, Bayan Escort Kayseri, Kayseri Eskort Bayan
Escort Bayan Ankara
Escort Bayan
Escort Ankara
Escort Ankara Bayan

Escort Bayan Ankara,
Escort Bayan,
Ankara Escort,
Ankara Escort Bayan,
Escort Bayan Ankara,
Escort Bayan,
Escort Ankara Bayan,
Ankara Escort,
Ankara Escort Bayan,
Escort Bayan Ankara
Ankara Escort Bayan
Escort Ankara
Bayan Ankara Escort
Escort Ankara
Escort Bursa
Escort Ankara Bayan
Ankara Escort Bayan
Ankara Günlük Kiralık Ev
Escort Ankara Bayan
Thanks for sharing. Very impressive

 
At 2:43 AM, Blogger yanmaneee said...

kd 12 shoes
yeezy boost 350 v2
moncler coat
pandora outlet
air jordan
jordan shoes
supreme new york
supreme hoodie
kevin durant shoes
kyrie shoes

 

Post a Comment

<< Home